Social Media Marketing vs. Traditional Marketing: Which Delivers Better ROI?

Every company wants their marketing efforts to be the most productive ones as they try to get the best result for the money invested. Regardless of the goals (lead generation, sales growth, brand awareness, customer retention), it's essential to learn what marketing channels have the best ROI (return on investment).

Decades ago, companies used newspapers, magazines, TV shows, radio jingles, billboards, and direct mailing to get their marketing message across and interact with customers. Nowadays, businesses have more marketing channels to promote their goods/services and communicate with customers. One of the most common questions business owners ask is whether it's better to invest in social media marketing or traditional marketing.

Everything depends on the business audience, products/services, budget, and analytics. Mostly, social media marketing is more flexible, dynamic, and analytical than traditional marketing channels. In this article, we will discuss the differences between social media marketing and traditional marketing and find out which one is the best to get the best ROI.

What Is Traditional Marketing?

Traditional marketing refers to any marketing activities using traditional/old media to promote a company's goods/services. It includes radio, newspapers, magazines, billboards, direct mailing, and catalogs. Traditional marketing is used to promote a particular product, strengthen the company image, build a recognizable brand at the global/local levels, and support political campaigns, among others.

The main advantage of traditional marketing is that it has had decades of experience working with customers. At the same time, the primary disadvantage is that it's hard to measure the ROI of traditional marketing efforts.

What Is Social Media Marketing?

Social media marketing (SMM) refers to any marketing activities using social media networks to promote a company's goods/services. There are various social media networks, but the most popular platforms are Instagram, Facebook, LinkedIn, TikTok, Pinterest, YouTube, Twitter/X, etc.

Unlike traditional marketing channels, social media marketing allows sellers to build relationships with customers. Social media marketing campaigns include organic and paid content and community management.

Thanks to analytics, SMM allows monitoring and optimizing the performance of a social media campaign to get the best ROI. Now, let's take a closer look at the characteristics of social media marketing and traditional marketing and find out the advantages and disadvantages of social media marketing and traditional marketing.

Social Media Marketing ROI: Why Measuring Matters

ROI (return on investment) is a financial metric that determines the amount of money earned from an initial investment. The higher the ROI, the more profit an investment brings to a company.

Traditional marketing campaigns are usually hard to optimize because there's no accurate way to define which channels worked well, which audience segments responded poorly, which marketing initiatives brought the best ROI, and what traditional media (newspapers, magazines, TV shows) were the most profitable. It's hard to optimize and reallocate funds within traditional marketing campaigns.

What You Can Track With Social Media Marketing

At the same time, with social media marketing, you will get all the necessary insights and analytics to understand what marketing activities, posts, and stories worked well and brought the best ROI. You will also be able to take these insights and use them in other marketing campaigns to get the best ROI for your business.

In addition, with social media marketing, you will know:

• What social media channels gave you the best ROI
• What ad formats were the most profitable
• What audience segments responded the best to your marketing campaigns
• What content types drove the best engagement
• Who your most active customers are
• Which social media channels drove the best ROI for your business

Thanks to the mentioned benefits of social media marketing, you will be able to optimize your social media campaigns and get the best ROI. Now, let's move to the next strong side of social media marketing and discuss why it's better than traditional marketing.

Social Media Marketing vs Traditional Marketing: Key Differences

Now, let's move to the key differences between social media marketing and traditional marketing and find out why social media marketing can bring a better ROI than traditional marketing.

1. Audience Targeting

One of the significant advantages of social media marketing is that it allows precise audience targeting. Thanks to social media platforms, you can target your customers based on their personal characteristics, interests, behavior, occupation, geography, intent, etc.

Traditional marketing channels do not allow such precise audience segmentation. For example, you cannot target a specific group of people with a newspaper ad or magazine ad.

With social media marketing, you can narrow your audience and only spend your marketing budget on those who have a high intention to become your customers. If you want to get the best value for your marketing budget, you should launch a social media campaign with precise audience targeting to get the best ROI for your business.

Evolve Digital can help you launch a social media marketing campaign and ensure that your marketing budget is spent on the right marketing activities. If you want to learn how to get the best value for your marketing budget, contact Evolve Digital today.

2. Cost Comparison

Most traditional marketing channels are expensive, whereas social media marketing is a great choice for businesses with a limited budget. A traditional marketing campaign requires a decent budget for radio ads, newspaper ads, and billboards.

At the same time, a social media marketing campaign allows starting with a small budget and scaling the most effective marketing strategies. Thanks to social media marketing analytics, you can A/B test various ad formats and budgets and only invest in the ad formats that bring the best ROI.

You can also pinpoint the most responsive audience segments and only spend your marketing budget on them. Thus, unlike traditional marketing, social media marketing allows optimizing the marketing campaign and only investing in profitable segments. In addition, social media marketing is more cost-effective and profitable than traditional marketing.

3. Customer Engagement

Traditional marketing channels do not allow for two-way communication between a company and its customers. It means that a company cannot engage with its customers; it can only send marketing messages to its audience.

At the same time, social media marketing allows two-way communication between a company and its customers. It means that a company can engage with its customers. Moreover, customers expect brands to engage with them.

Engagement is critical to building relationships with customers and strengthening the brand image. Besides, engaged customers are more likely to become repeat buyers/payers and brand ambassadors, which is essential for sustainable growth. Traditional marketing channels cannot help build relationships between a company and its customers.

4. Speed and Flexibility

Markets and customer needs are constantly changing, so marketing campaigns need to be flexible and dynamic to suit the ever-changing environment. Unfortunately, traditional marketing channels are not that flexible and slow to adapt to the changing environment.

If a traditional marketing campaign goes viral, it will be hard to scale it because traditional marketing channels (newspapers, magazines, billboards, radio) require time to make changes to the campaign.

At the same time, social media marketing allows being flexible and adaptive to the changing environment. If a social media post or ad goes viral, a company can update the post/ad and scale it quickly.

In a few words, unlike traditional marketing, social media marketing allows being flexible and dynamic to ensure that marketing campaigns are aligned with the needs of the target audience. In addition, social media marketing allows changing the content, posts, and stories in real-time.

5. Brand Awareness

Traditional marketing channels are mostly used for brand image building and brand awareness. For example, companies use newspapers, magazines, and billboards to promote their brand and let the world know about their goods/services.

At the same time, social media marketing can be used to increase brand awareness. Every post, story, reaction from customers, comments, and likes contribute to brand awareness. In addition, unlike traditional marketing channels, social media marketing allows engaging with customers and turning them into brand ambassadors.

Thus, social media marketing is a great choice for increasing brand awareness and getting the best ROI for a marketing budget.

If you want to increase your brand awareness and get the best value for your marketing budget, Evolve Digital will help you launch a social media marketing campaign that will organically grow your brand awareness. Contact Evolve Digital today and learn how to get the best value for your marketing budget.

When Is Traditional Marketing Better Than Social Media Marketing?

Despite the many advantages of social media marketing, traditional marketing channels have their advantages. In some cases, traditional marketing channels are the best choice, while in others, social media marketing is a more profitable choice.

Best Use Cases for Traditional Marketing

Traditional marketing channels may be a better choice when:

• A company wants to target baby boomers or older generations
• A company wants to create local brand awareness
• A company wants to promote a new product/service
• A company wants to run a national advertising campaign
• A company wants to complement its digital marketing campaign with traditional marketing

In some cases, a combination of social media marketing and traditional marketing channels brings the best results. It's vital to choose the best marketing channel(s) for a business.

When Is Social Media Marketing Better Than Traditional Marketing?

Social media marketing channels have more flexibility, targeting options, analytics, engagement-building potential, and optimization options than traditional marketing channels. Mostly, social media marketing is a better choice than traditional marketing, but there are some cases when traditional marketing is a better choice than social media marketing.

Best Use Cases for Social Media Marketing

Social media marketing is better than traditional marketing when a company wants to:

• Generate leads
• Drive traffic
• Increase sales
• Grow its brand
• Engage with customers
• Measure campaign performance
• Optimize its marketing efforts
• Boost customer retention
• Scale its marketing campaign

With social media marketing, a company can constantly optimize its online presence and get the best ROI for a marketing budget. If you're looking for ways to scale your marketing campaigns and optimize your marketing efforts, Evolve Digital will help you choose the best marketing channels for your business.

What Is the Best Marketing Strategy: Social Media Marketing or Traditional Marketing?

The best marketing strategy is to combine social media marketing and traditional marketing. For example, traditional media channels can be used to build a company's image/recognition, whereas social media marketing can be used to engage with customers and turn them into brand ambassadors.

In addition, social media marketing can also retarget customers and encourage repeat sales. Traditional marketing channels and social media marketing channels, combined together, can bring the best results.

In a few words, when discussing the ROI of social media marketing and traditional marketing channels, it's essential to remember that social media marketing is a flexible and dynamic marketing channel with many targeting and optimization options.

If you want to get the best value for your marketing budget and increase brand awareness, it's a good idea to invest in a professional social media marketing campaign. Thanks to social media campaign analytics, you will be able to optimize your marketing campaign and get the best ROI for your marketing budget.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

Is social media marketing better than traditional marketing?

For most companies, social media marketing is better than traditional marketing because it's more flexible, allows more targeting options, provides analytics, and is easier to optimize.

Does traditional marketing still work?

Social media marketing usually works better than traditional marketing because it's more flexible and profitable.

Which businesses need social media marketing?

Most businesses can benefit from social media marketing, but it's crucial for e-commerce, start-ups, healthcare, professionals, luxury brands, and B2B companies.

Can a business use both social media marketing and traditional marketing?

Yes, a business can and should use both marketing channels. It's a great idea to combine traditional marketing and social media marketing to get the best results.

How can a business measure the ROI of social media marketing?

A business can measure the ROI of social media marketing by analyzing engagement rates, traffic, leads, sales, and cost per acquisition.